About Us
Lucky Leaf
Contact Us
Locate a Broker

Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie

Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie

This rich pumpkin pie uses apple butter in the custard and is a holiday favorite.

Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie


Servings: makes 24 servings

3 cups canned pumpkin 
3 cups (about 30 oz.) MUSSELMAN'S® Premium Apple Butter
3 cups heavy cream or evaporated milk 
3/4 cup dark brown sugar
9 large eggs 
1 1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon 
3/4 tsp. each ground ginger, nutmeg and kosher salt
3 x 9-in. deep-dish pie pastry shell, unbaked


  1. In bowl combine pumpkin, apple butter, cream, brown sugar, eggs, spices and salt; mix until smooth.
  2. Divide evenly among 3 pie shells. Place on sheet pans and bake in 375°F oven for 40-45 minutes or until slightly firm to the touch.
  3. Remove from heat and cool to room temperature on racks.


If, in your oven, pie crust begins to brown excessively, place foil halo over crust edges (cut 9" circles of foil; cut out center leaving 1-inch wide ring of foil).

More Apple Butter & Specialty recipes

View All


See how our products and recipes can meet the needs of any foodservice segment, from K-12 to healthcare.

Find your Segment

Bulk Ingredients

Ready to use and available in aseptic packaging, our bulk ingredients can help you save time, labor and money.

Explore Now

Straight from the Orchard, Straight to Your Inbox